The Best Cock Sleeves and Cock Sheaths (Designed for Hard Cocks)

While reviewing the best cock sleeves and sheaths I realized that there seems to be a bit of confusion on terminology. This review focuses on the best cock sleeves and sheaths for hard cocks. These sex toys can be used for both masturbation and penetration and are not appropriate to assist with any erectile dysfunction issues. Other more rigid sleeves, sheaths or even penis extenders are designed for penetration only. So, before we get started on the review, let's take a quick look at the differences between product types.

Cock Enhancers Defined

Rocco Breeder Cock Sleeve by Perfect Fit translucent SilaSkin. Best Cock Sleeve

Cock Sleeve – A penis sleeve covering that surrounds the penis shaft but not the head. Used for masturbation or insertion with a partner. Provides added girth only around the shaft while allowing the head to be exposed for added male enjoyment. Fits snuggly around the shaft only or may also have a strap around the balls to hold in place. (Pictured: Rocco Breeder Cock Sleeve by Perfect Fit)

Perfect Fit Fat Boy Micro Ribbed Cock Sheath in 7.5"

Cock Sheath – A penis covering that surrounds the entire penis and is often secured with a strap around the balls. Used for masturbation or insertion with partner. Provides primarily added girth with negligible length enhancement. (Pictured: Fat Boy Micro Ribbed Cock Sheath by Perfect Fit)

Vixen VixSkin Colossus Cock Extender

Cock Extender with Ball Strap – A penis covering that surrounds the entire penis but also adds additional length to the end of the penis. Used for insertion with a partner. Typically harder and less flexible than a cock sheath. It provides added girth and length and is held in place with a ball strap. (Pictured: Vixen VixSkin Colossus at LoveHoney)

Custom Fit, Ultra-Realistic, Strapless Cock Extenders – A new category in penis sheaths, this penis covering also surrounds the entire penis to add both girth and length but does not require a ball strap. Instead, it is designed to fit very snuggly and uses the naturally occurring air-suction to keep it in place. Breakthroughs in materials and design have allowed companies like Blissful Creations to create these masterpieces with custom internal sizing for the perfect fit. (Pictured: The Mailman by Blissful Creations)

See Full Review of Mailman Cock Sleeve Here

Quest for the best cock sleeve

In my youth, an actual cock sleeve was like the mythical holy grail of masturbation. Many men won’t admit it or have hidden these memories at some unreachable depths, but there is a time in every male's life when he quests to put his penis in just about anything. That’s what makes the classic scene in “American Pie” so relatable when Jim slides his penis into that hot apple pie. Saranwrap between pillows, paper towel rolls (bad idea), bubble wrap; all good options in the eyes of a virgin. Today's youth have been robbed of such imagination (another reason to hate Amazon if you’re a left-leaning progressive in Seattle). Just type Amazon in your browser, do a quick search, order with mom’s stored CC, archive order history, intercept package at door (the tricky part), and voila, you have a beautiful cock sleeve or cock sheath. (Not recommending this course of action, but it seems a likely scenario for many a horny youth.)

Reasons for using a cock sleeve, cock sheath, or extender

  • Masturbation with or without a partner (cock sleeves and cock sheaths)
  • Feelings of having an inadequately sized penis (often only in our own minds… Average erect penis size in US is 5.1″ to 5.6″ in length and 4.7″ in circumference. (See Medical News Today)
  • Fantasy of giving or taking an unusually large cock
  • Erectile Issues from cumming too fast to problems maintaining erection
  • Role-Playing (Giving/taking a different cock can be expanded to imaging sex with a different partner or species (Bad Dragon)
  • Increased sensation for user or receiver due to increased pressure from increased width/length
  • Enhance other toys (For example, covering a dildo that might be too rigid or slender

Why everyone should try a cock sleeve or sheath

For me, cock sleeves and sheaths are fun for role-playing in particular. I can pretend to be a gift for the queen or whatever. She gets to feel something a little different, pretend its someone else with a different/larger cock that surprises her a bit and takes a few minutes to get acquainted with. She gets an unusually full feeling inside and a bit more friction while my cock gets squeezed a bit tighter by the sleeve or sheath and the pressure of her pussy around it. I get the visual of my huge cock (ever man's juvenile fantasy) spreading her apart. It's hot as fuck. With that in mind, my solution/tool needs to increase girth and not length in any significant way. Any longer than my natural length is uncomfortable for her and I would say that my length and girth are naturally proportional so increasing the girth is plenty already. Increasing girth is tricky too as it has to be done in a natural and soft way to be really pleasurable for her especially since increasing my girth honestly creates a cock that is too big for daily use. It's a once a month or maybe even a twice a year type of cock for her so it needs to be as forgiving as possible. With that in mind, I did a ton of research and ultimately landed on 3 products all from Perfect Fit (due to the SilaSkin material) to do this deep dive.

Perfect Fit Solutions (the best non-realistic cock sleeves and sheaths)

The Best Cock Sleeves and Cock Sheaths from Perfect Fit
Perfect Fit Fat Boy Product Line

I've had a Perfect Fit Fat Boy Thin for a few years which I've used for both masturbation and penetration. It is very durable and pliable with a strap to go around the balls to keep in place for penetration. It has a pattern of textured nubs and ribs on the inside that creates a nice friction against the penis. For masturbation, you should use a lot of lube, as you are sliding the sheath up and down your cock but I would recommend less lube for actual penetration/sex. Just use a small amount of lube on the inside and a bit more on the outside. This way the sheath stays tighter to the penis and your partner will get a bit more friction since the penis is not slipping around inside the sheath. Surprisingly, you still get a ton of sensation and if you think it is as sexy as I do (watching your partner take a huge cock), it's pretty easy to actually cum during sex.

For this article, I'm focused on the Sleeves and Sheaths because I haven't seen an extender that I really want to try yet and I'm personally long enough that additional length is just uncomfortable for my partner. She is also really critical of harder dildo's and many extenders seem to have that type of less flexible material in order to keep the extended head from being floppy.

I bought that Fat Boy Thin (then called the Fat Boy Slim which I'm pretty sure had some issues with search) as part of a role-playing set-up I created. It wasn't something that she asked for or something that I wanted to use because I felt like my penis was too short or too skinny. I just wanted to create a fantasy situation where I was another man and I thought that a different sized penis would be a fun way to take the fantasy to another level. Please note too that I don't buy into our obsession with penis size, bigger is not always better, but in this case, it is the excitement of taking/giving something a bit different and out of the norm. Before I found the Fat Boy Thin, I bought a few cheap penis sleeves with a more aggressive texture on the outside. They were made from hard material, didn't feel comfortable to me, and felt less comfortable to her. Neither of us liked them and they were never used again. Then I went into research mode and came across Perfect Fit.

Perfect Fit Rocco Breeder Sleeve, Fat Boy Thin, and Fat Boy Micro Ribbed

My partner loved the whole role-play event with my first Perfect Fit Fat Boy Slim and we have used it many times since. Now, a few years later as I did the research for this article, I just couldn't find something that looked like it would compare so I decided to buy a few different types of Perfect Fit SilaSkin products to see which I liked best and if they had made improvements to the original Fat Boy Slim (Now called Fat Boy Thin). So, for this review, I purchased three products.

6.5″ Fat Boy Thin Cock Sheath by Perfect Fit

This was the exact version of the Fat Boy Thin that I purchased a few years back but my old Fat boy Thin was in black and I believe the black material isn't quite as good as the current clear SilaSkin (they seem to no longer sell the black). Hard to tell for sure as the SilaSkin will age and get a bit tackier over time but I do think they have made some material improvement in moving to only carry the clear version. Inside the textured ribs and nubs were identical and the outside remains a soft non-textured surface. For me, this size is a little small in length so there is a small gap between my pubic bone and the base of the sheath. This makes little difference in the feeling while having sex but it is visually better to have the base rest all the way against your base and I think that even though the material is very flexible, my penetration might be minorly shallower. The other key difference between the Thin and the other two is that the Thin is, a bit thinner. It essentially gives you an extra 0.5″ girth whereas the Breeder Sleeve and the Micro Ribbed Fat Boy provide an additional 0.7″ in girth. It seems minor but it is noticeable.

I've always loved the Fat Boy Thin and this one is just as good as the one I had before but after testing the Fat Boy Micro Ribbed I personally won't be buying a thin again. This is mainly because the largest size (6.5″) is just slightly short for me and my realization that the exterior smoothness doesn't provide enough texture to make things as pleasing as they can be for your partner. Enter the Fat Boy Micro Ribbed… (See Full Fat Boy Thin Review Here)

7.5″ Fat Boy Micro Ribbed Cock Sheath by Perfect Fit

I'm about 7.25″ long when fully erect so I was a bit nervous to try the 7.5″ version of the Fat Boy. In reality, I would say that this one is the tiniest bit long but it is so stretch that I can easily push it back toward my pubic bone. The texture is the same inside as the Fat Boy Thin but having a little more wiggle room for me actually provided a bit more friction during penetration. It also allows me to have my full penetration depth potential plus maybe a quarter inch. The 0.7″ of girth is only 0.2″ larger than the Thin model but I was worried it would be too much. It wasn't. In fact, she loved this and I don't think the extra girth was the reason. She liked it. It filled her up nicely. But it was the Micro Ribbing on the outside that provided additional texture and friction. This ended-up being a shorter session as we both came relatively quickly but if that's my worst complaint then we're doing ok. (See Full Fat Boy Micro Ribbed Review Here)

Rocco Breeder Cock Sleeve By Perfect Fit

The Rocco Breeder Cock Sleeve was one of those things that you find while looking for something else and are then like, “Where have you been my whole life.” It measures about 5″ in length with a tapered edge near the head where penetration would begin. The texture on the inside is the same as the other perfect fit toys but the outside has a herringbone like patterned ridges that are perfect for your partner's sensation. This is a great masturbator but it's best for penetration. I still can't believe how well it stays in place and how good the sensation is with your penis head exposed while still getting the interior pressure of your partner and the friction of the inside of the sleeve. This was my favorite. (See Full Rocco Breeder Review Here)

What About Realistic Cock Sheaths?

I hadn't expanded this page to talk much about realistic cock sheaths and sleeves because, up until now, I hadn't found one that I was really excited about. All the realistic cock sleeves seemed to trade a more realistic look for an uncomfortable feel. In addition to that, they never really seemed to fit in such a way that they actually looked realistic but instead looked like a toy extension hanging off your penis. Well, I'm excited to say that Blissful Creations has solved all of this and is ready to make your porn star huge cock fantasies come true. I've just completed my full review of The Mailman cock sheath here. This is a massive cock sheath to make your porn star fantasies cum true. The mailman has incredible attention to detail and is ultra-realistic in both look and feel. And, it's customized to fit your penis with internal length options ranging from 4″ to 7″ in 1/2″ increments.

Side note on cheap masturbation tool alternatives

Tenga Eggs are also a great, low-cost masturbation tool for men. They are not meant to last a long time and if you have a larger/longer penis you will likely break your egg after a session or two but they provide a pleasant sensation. These are not Cock Sheaths as they cannot be worn for penetration but for masturbation, they feel great and they still let you or your partner feel your head and shaft and get a good visual while masturbating. They come in a bunch of different textures and colors etc. so that can be fun too. Note again that these are not meant for penetration. They will break or get lost inside someone so just don't do it. Also note that if you are comparing prices on things like Tenga's and something like the Perfect Fit products, the Perfect Fit cock sleeves and sheaths will last for years where's the Tenga's will last for a few sessions.

Note: This article includes affiliate links. These links provide SexLoveCoffee.com with a small commission if a purchase is made on the linked website. This helps us to “keep the lights on” here at SexLoveCoffee, but it in no way impacts the substance of our review. All reviews are open and honest as is the nature and purpose of SexLoveCoffee.com.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top